Don’t Punish the Kids: Jackie Robinson West’s Forfeit of U.S. Little League Title is a Case of Adults Behaving Badly

13 Feb
In what was a happier moment, the kids from Chicago's Jackie Robinson West Little League squad celebrate winning the U.S. Championship in the Little League World Series. The title was recently stripped from Jackie Robinson West because of rules violations.  Photo by Huffington Post.

In what was a happier moment, the kids from Chicago’s Jackie Robinson West Little League squad celebrate winning the U.S. Championship in the Little League World Series. The title was recently stripped from Jackie Robinson West because of rules violations. Photo by Huffington Post.

By Chris Murray
For the Chris Murray Report and the Philadelphia Sunday Sun

The story of Chicago’s Jackie Robinson West Little League baseball team being stripped of their U.S. Little League World Series title is the sad tale of an epic fail on the part of the adults.

Little League International stripped the squad of its championship because team officials violated the rules for expanding the boundaries from where they can get players without asking permission of the neighboring districts.

From all I’ve read and heard about this situation, I can’t help but feel that the only visible heroes here are the kids on the team itself who performed excellently on the field.

All of the adults—the team’s coaches and administrators, Evergreen Park Little League Vice President Chris Janes, the so-called “whistleblower” who may have played fast and loose with the rules himself, and the Little League International organization—have acquitted themselves badly.

From the start, the coaches and organizers of Jackie Robinson West, should have talked with Little League about the team’s boundaries JRW coach Darold Butler should have realized that this whole thing was going to come out at some point, especially with all the national publicity the team received. Winning should never come at the expense of integrity.

But the coach wasn’t alone in his bad behavior. The administrator for Illinois District 4 and Little League Baseball International’s should have had a better system of making sure each team is in compliance.

But that said, there will be no medals given to Janes of Evergreen Park either. After his squad got thumped 43-2 in four innings by JRW, he turned into Little League’s version of Inspector Javert in Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables, determined to go after this group of kids in the same way Javert went after Jean Valjean.

Janes sent an email to Little League Baseball that appeared in, the website that broke the story. This email implied that he would take legal action if Little League Baseball didn’t look into the allegations against Jackie Robinson West.

I guess watching his kids get mollywhopped by a group of inner city Black kids that didn’t play the so-called “traditional” way caused something to snap.

Adult entitlement is a helluva drug.

The vigor with which Janes went after this team of kids, and let’s be honest here and admit that snatching an achievement from a group of kids is what this is all about, smacks of racism to many in Chicago.

But while many were too polite to say it, Venisa Green, mother of JRW player Brandon Green, wasn’t. When you go after someone’s child, the gloves, in this case baseball gloves, tend to come off.

“It is amazing to me that whenever African-Americans exceed the expectations, that there is going to be fault that is going to be found in what it is we do,” Green said to the Chicago Sun-Times.

Now would Janes have made these allegations if JRW not beaten his team so badly or had they not won the U.S. Championship? If Evergreen Park had beaten JRW, would Janes have gone through the pains complaining about the team’s boundaries?

No, he probably wouldn’t have, said the Rev. Michael Phleger, pastor of Chicago’s St. Sabina Church. He took part in a rally in support of the team organized by the Rev. Jesse Jackson.

“Are you telling me that the same kind of obsession of stalking, going over this month, would have happened-would have been done—if the Las Vegas team had won?” Phleger said. “I’m sorry. I live in America. And I believe that racism is in the midst of this thing.”

In yet another example of how the adults screwed this thing up, ABC-7 TV in Chicago interviewed an African-American mother whose son played in the Evergreen Park Little League despite not living within it’s boundaries. Renee Cannon-Young said her son’s paperwork was all filled out for her to sign, complete with a falsified residence.

“I was told that although he was not a resident of Evergreen Park, they were going to fix that so that he could play,” Cannon-Young said.

The ABC-7 report also said it was common practice for Little League teams to recruit from beyond their designated boundaries.
Little League Baseball is supposed to be that field of dreams where it’s all about the kids and the pure joy associated with the love of the game. Instead, it has become a microcosm of all that is wrong in the world of adults.

If it has any semblance of understanding and compassion, Little League International should restore the U.S. Title to the kids of Jackie Robinson West because they did nothing wrong but play well in the game they love.

It was the grownups that broke the rules and acted like petulant children.

It’s too bad that the players of Jackie Robinson West, the kids who did everything right, are the ones made to pay for their sins.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​


7 Responses to “Don’t Punish the Kids: Jackie Robinson West’s Forfeit of U.S. Little League Title is a Case of Adults Behaving Badly”

  1. bob 123 March 16, 2015 at 6:12 pm #

    Awful, awful reporting. Did you do any fact checking prior to running this? Why did you spend more time making Janes the villian than calling out the cheaters? Why did you spend any time entertaining the notion of racism. Do you know Janes is married to a black women? Did you know Everygreen Parks team was made up of 4 hispanic, 4 black, and three whitw kids? Did you know Ms. Green was one of the parents who lived outside the boundaries? She has a PHD…think she was ignorant to the fact they were cheating? Did you know 5/9 starters on JRW’s team lived outside their boundaries? One last question…did you really know any thing before running this?

  2. timschnieders July 2, 2017 at 2:26 am #


    I’m so excited to tell you something really important, so I decided to write you a message, please read it here

    All the best, goldstartalent

  3. timschnieders July 6, 2017 at 8:53 pm #


    I think I ‘ve just found some information that may be helpful to you, read it here please

    Brittany Wellman

  4. timschnieders July 11, 2017 at 7:27 pm #


    Take a look at that article I’ve just read, it’s just awesome, please read it here

    Typos courtesy of my iPhone, Virgil Newby

  5. timschnieders July 20, 2017 at 2:16 pm #


    Some are obvious, like the three floors that lie between you and your Wi-Fi box; others are a little

    Steve Long

  6. timschnieders July 31, 2017 at 2:35 am #


    There is something I wanted to show you, it’s just some really great stuff! Just take a look

    Shannon Fisher

  7. timschnieders August 15, 2017 at 11:30 am #


    I should let you know I am absolutely new to this kind of work, so I decided to ask you some questions about it, please answer them here

    Speak to you later, Milton Carter

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: